CitySearch
  Advertising Info   About Us   Contact Us   Feedback   Site Index

 News
 War on Terror
 Metro
 North County
 State/The West
 Nation
 Mexico
 World
 Business
 Technology
 Science
 Politics
 Military
 Education
 Travel
 Solutions
 Special Reports
 Features
 Weather
 Forums
 Columnists
 U-T Daily Paper
 U-T Archives
 AP Wire

$1.5 million suit filed in the library cat case


By John Berhman
UNION-TRIBUNE STAFF WRITER

November 28, 2001

ESCONDIDO -- Richard Espinosa, whose assistance dog allegedly was attacked by the Public Library's pet cat last year, filed a lawsuit against the city yesterday seeking $1.5 million in damages.

Espinosa alleges in his suit, which he prepared himself and filed in Superior Court in Vista, that his rights as a disabled person as well as his civil rights were violated.

Espinosa, who lives in Vista, was a reporter for the North County Times when the incident occurred Nov. 16, 2000. In his 13-page suit, Espinosa says he suffers from anxiety attacks and that his California-certified assistance dog accompanies him to help him deal with them.

Previous stories:
  • Librarian throws the book at feisty cat, exiles her to a home (May 23, 2001)
  • Notorious library cat clobbers another dog (May 19, 2001)
  • Library patrons litter-ally lionize a controversial cat (May 11, 2001)
  • Escondido gets $1.5 million claim; library cat allegedly assaulted dog (May 4, 2001)
     
  • Espinosa says he was on assignment when he and Kimba, a Labrador mix that weighs about 50 pounds, entered the library and the cat attacked his dog. The cat, called L.C. for library cat, often sat on a pillow near the entrance.

    Espinosa says the library had a sign that said "No Animals" except guide dogs, which violated his right and those of others who use assistance dogs to enter the city library.

    Espinosa also alleges that a library administrator and a patron chastised him for ignoring the sign and bringing Kimba into the library and that police did not promptly respond to his call for assistance.

    Before officers arrived, Espinosa left to take Kimba to a veterinarian, who charged $46.49 for the treatment, according to a claim Espinosa filed with the city in May.

    Espinosa says in his suit that he "suffers life-threatening anaphylactic reactions when exposed to cats" and that the city caused him "to come into an unknown and very dangerous and unsafe situation striking terror in (him) and causing him lasting physical and emotional injury" and permanent damage to his dog.

    He contends the city violated both the California Disabled Act of 1990 and the California Unruh Civil Rights Act by its "continuing policy of putting the welfare of their dangerous cat above people with disabilities."

    In the suit, Espinosa, says he has been diagnosed with many disorders, including bilateral pulmonary emboli, asthma, diabetes, gout and, more recently, with chronic pain syndrome, borderline personality disorder, major depressive disorder, panic disorder and post-traumatic stress disorder.

    In May, L.C. attacked a terrier outside the library. A few days after that incident, City Librarian Laura Mitchell put the 12-pound cat on an "indefinite vacation" at the home of a library employee.

    L.C. was a kitten when it was donated to the library by a homeless woman in 1994.

    John Berhman: (760) 752-6730; john.berhman@uniontrib.com

     






    Yellow Pages

    Search by
    Company Name:

     

    Local Guides

    Cars
    Coupons
    Eldercare
    Financial Guide
    Health
    Homes
    Jobs
    Legal Guide
    Shopping

    Site Index | Contact SignOn | UTads.com | About SignOn | Advertise on SignOn | Make SignOn your homepage
    About the Union-Tribune | Contact the Union-Tribune
    © Copyright 2001 Union-Tribune Publishing Co.